Clinical opinion · Zac Eaton, Registered Nurse and Clinical Nurse Consultant
The Vineland is a good tool with a specific job. The problem is what happened when it became the default for every job, including the ones it was never built for.
This is a clinician's view of the two adaptive behaviour scales we use most, where each earns its place, and what a decade of the NDIA treating one of them as the standard has done to assessment practice. It is a position piece. Where I am reporting evidence I say so, and where I am giving an opinion I say that too.
First, the plain answer
What a Vineland assessment is.
The Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales, Third Edition (Vineland-3) measures adaptive behaviour: the everyday skills a person uses to communicate, look after themselves and get along with others. It scores three core domains, Communication, Daily Living Skills and Socialization, and combines them into an Adaptive Behavior Composite. It is completed with a parent, caregiver or teacher, by structured interview or questionnaire. The person being assessed does not sit a test (Sparrow et al., 2016).
It is not a diagnosis and it is not an IQ test. It describes what someone does, day to day, without help. For autism, the NDIA lists it second on its preferred evidence list, directly after the DSM-5 diagnosis (National Disability Insurance Agency [NDIA], 2026).
Where the Vineland is the right tool
Young children, and anyone who can't yet tell you themselves.
A long research record
The Vineland family has been the most used adaptive behaviour measure in autism research for decades, so a score sits inside a large body of comparison data.
Built for informants
When the person is a preschooler, has significant intellectual disability, or cannot reliably describe their own functioning, an informant measure is the only honest option, and the Vineland's interview format does it well.
Recognised by the planner
Because it is on the NDIA's list, a Vineland score is read and understood by the people making the funding decision. That is a real advantage and I don't pretend otherwise.
Where it isn't
The Vineland-3 has no self-report form. The ABAS-3 does.
That single design difference decides whose account of a life goes into the report.
| Feature | Vineland-3 | ABAS-3 |
|---|---|---|
| Who answers | Parent, caregiver or teacher. Interview or questionnaire. | Parent, caregiver or teacher, and from age 16 the person themselves, on the Adult Form. |
| Age range | Birth through adulthood | Birth to 89 |
| Structure | Communication, Daily Living Skills, Socialization, optional Motor and Maladaptive Behavior; Adaptive Behavior Composite | Ten skill areas grouped into Conceptual, Social and Practical domains; General Adaptive Composite |
| Self-report | None | Yes, Adult Form (self-rated or rated by another adult) |
| Best use, in my practice | Early childhood; people who cannot self-report; where the NDIA will read it and nothing else will do | Older teenagers and adults; anyone capable of rating their own functioning; comparing a person's view with a parent's or teacher's |
Sources for the tool descriptions: Sparrow et al. (2016); Harrison and Oakland (2015). The "best use" row is my clinical judgement, not a published recommendation.
What I think happened
The NDIA wanted a standard tool. No single tool has the reliability, depth, breadth and reach to be one. So the Vineland got the job anyway.
When an agency publishes a preferred evidence list, the list becomes the standard of practice. Clinicians choose the tool the planner expects to see, because choosing anything else puts the participant's funding at risk. That is a rational response to the incentive, and it is sector-wide. It is not a failing of individual clinicians.
Assessment stopped being individualised and became standardised. The question "which tool fits this person and this decision?" was replaced by "which tool does the Agency want?" For a 17-year-old who can describe their own week perfectly well, that means their functioning is reported entirely through their parent, and their own perception is nowhere in the file.
I do not believe the NDIA chose an informant-only tool in order to set autistic people's own accounts aside. I do think that is what mandating it in every context has produced. A system that structurally cannot hear from the person about their own life, where they are perfectly able to tell it, entrenches an old assumption: that autistic people are unreliable reporters of their own experience. That is my position, and I hold it as a clinical and ethical one rather than a research finding.
Why self-report matters clinically
The gap between the two accounts is data.
When autistic adults rate their own functioning and an informant rates it too, the two accounts often diverge (Sandercock et al., 2020). That is sometimes read as proof that self-report is unreliable. I read it the other way: the divergence is clinically informative, and you only see it if you collect both.
In family-centred practice the stakes are concrete. If every data point about a young person's social functioning comes from a parent, there is nothing in the file that tells you how the young person experiences the same situations, which is exactly what you need to plan support around. The difference between "my son has no friends" and "I have two people I message every day and I don't want more" is the whole intervention.
There is a second reason the label-first habit matters. IQ and diagnostic level are poor predictors of adaptive functioning in autistic people (Alvares et al., 2020). Funding tied to a label, or to a single informant score standing in for one, misses the person twice.
What we do instead
Choose the tool for the person and the decision, then cross-confirm.
Both, where the person can self-report
The ABAS-3 Adult Form for the person's own account from 16, alongside an informant measure, so the report shows both and names the gap.
The Vineland-3 where it fits
Early childhood, significant intellectual disability, and where an NDIA process will only read a Vineland score.
Never one scale alone
Adaptive behaviour sits beside the SRS-2, SPM-2 and D-REF, structured interview and observation, so the findings are cross-confirmed rather than resting on one questionnaire.
The person's account, in their words
Where someone can tell us how their week goes, the report says so, in their words, next to the scores.
What changes next
The NDIA's list is about to matter less. The question underneath it matters more.
The NDIA has announced that new framework planning begins from 1 April 2027 for participants 16 and over, with a Support Needs Assessment conducted by NDIA assessors using the I-CAN v6 rather than reports from treating clinicians; those details come from the Agency, not the Act, and could still change. The National Disability Insurance Scheme Amendment (Securing the NDIS for Future Generations) Act 2026 has also defined functional capacity, from 27 August 2026, as what a person can do without help from other people or aids beyond the everyday ones they would normally use (and, for a child, beyond help that is usual for their age), judged as far as possible apart from their environment and personal circumstances (s 9B). Disability representative organisations have raised that no validation of the I-CAN v6 in autistic cohorts has been published (Autism Aspergers Advocacy Australia, 2025), and submissions to the Joint Standing Committee have argued the tool's design sits poorly with the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (Gregory, 2025).
Whatever the tool, the question this post is about does not go away: does the assessment hear from the person, and does it see the environment they live in? I take that up in a separate practice note on the reforms.
Functional assessments at Unified Care Solutions
Vineland-3, ABAS-3 and the person's own account, administered and interpreted by a Registered Nurse.
Telehealth Australia-wide, in person around Ballarat. About our functional assessments, or start with what a functional capacity assessment is. Referring someone? Information for referrers.
Common questions
What people usually ask.
Does my child have to do anything for a Vineland?
No. The Vineland-3 is completed with a parent, caregiver or teacher. Your child does not sit a test.
Will the NDIA accept an ABAS-3 instead of a Vineland?
The NDIA's published list names the Vineland for autism, so where a decision will turn on that list we include it. For older teenagers and adults we add the ABAS-3 so the person's own account is in the report too.
Can either be done by telehealth?
Yes. Both are interviews or questionnaires, which work well by video.
Can I see the questions beforehand?
The items are copyrighted and are not published. What helps is thinking about what the person does independently across a typical week, and, for older teenagers and adults, asking them the same question.
Does this change under the new NDIS planning framework?
From April 2027 the NDIA's own Support Needs Assessment is intended to drive budgets for participants 16 and over. Clinical assessments will still matter for goals, supports and evidence of change. We'll update this post as the NDIA publishes detail. For the planning meeting itself, our free Before the meeting tool helps you put a normal week on one page.
References
Alvares, G. A., Bebbington, K., Cleary, D., Evans, K., Glasson, E. J., Maybery, M. T., Pillar, S., Uljarević, M., Varcin, K., Wray, J., & Whitehouse, A. J. O. (2020). The misnomer of "high functioning autism": Intelligence is an imprecise predictor of functional abilities at diagnosis. Autism, 24(1), 221–232. https://doi.org/10.1177/1362361319852831
Autism Aspergers Advocacy Australia. (2025, September 26). A4 response to NDIS selecting I-CAN assessment tool. https://a4.org.au/node/2746
Gregory, P. (2025). The I-CAN tool: Embedding of ableism within the NDIA. A disability rights analysis (Supplementary submission to the Joint Standing Committee on the NDIS, Annual Report No. 1 of the 48th Parliament, Submission 12).
Harrison, P. L., & Oakland, T. (2015). Adaptive Behavior Assessment System, Third Edition (ABAS-3). Western Psychological Services.
National Disability Insurance Agency. (2026). What are examples of disability evidence. https://www.ndis.gov.au/applying/gathering-evidence/what-are-examples-disability-evidence
Sandercock, R. K., Lamarche, E. M., Klinger, M. R., & Klinger, L. G. (2020). Assessing the convergence of self-report and informant measures for adults with autism spectrum disorder. Autism, 24(8), 2256–2268. https://doi.org/10.1177/1362361320942981
Sparrow, S. S., Cicchetti, D. V., & Saulnier, C. A. (2016). Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales, Third Edition (Vineland-3). Pearson.