Friendship advice that backfires, and what to try instead

“Just go up and say hi.” “Just ignore them.” “Make friends with the popular kids.” Most of us have said at least one of these to our kids. They sound sensible, and they come from a good place. They just don’t tend to hold up in the real world, and when advice from a trusted adult fails, kids rarely blame the advice. They decide the problem is them.

This free guide goes through eight pieces of friendship advice autistic and neurodivergent kids and teens hear often, why each one tends to misfire, and a small shift to try instead. No sign-up, and you’re welcome to share it with anyone it would help.

Joining in and getting to know people

The advice makes sense to adults. Kids’ groups run on different rules.

Adult advice tends to assume that being direct, polite and confident is what wins people over. Between kids, the unspoken rules are closer to this: watch first, fit the topic, and let people warm to you. That gap is where most of this advice goes wrong.

“Just go up and say hi.”

Why it misfires

A group that is already talking is a closed circle. A cold hello asks them to stop and make room for someone new, which is why it so often gets a strange look or no response at all.

Try instead

Watch and listen first. Work out what they are talking about, then join in on that topic.

“Ask them lots of questions about themselves.”

Why it misfires

One question after another starts to feel like an interview, and the other person ends up doing all the work. Conversations that feel like interviews tend to go nowhere.

Try instead

Trade information. Share a little, ask a little, and listen for something you both like. When you find it, stay on it for a while.

“Be funny. Make them laugh.”

Why it misfires

Humour is risky with people who don’t know you yet. A joke that lands at home can miss with new kids, and your child may not see that it missed.

Try instead

Start a little more serious with new people. Save the jokes for once they know you, and watch whether people are laughing with you.

A quick way to practise the first one. Next time you’re out together, pick a group of people chatting nearby and ask your child what they think the topic is. Working out the topic from the outside is the hard part, so it’s worth practising on its own.

Teasing, and choosing friends

Who your child puts effort into matters as much as how.

Two of the most common pieces of advice point kids at the wrong people: the ones doing the teasing, and the ones with the most status. Neither is where friendships tend to come from.

“Just ignore them.” or “Give it back to them.”

Why it misfires

Teasing is a bid for a reaction. Silence or walking off can read as one, so it keeps going. Teasing back escalates things and often lands your child in trouble.

Try instead

A short, bored response, then move on. Teasing that gets no payoff tends to stop.

Physical bullying or threats are different. This advice is for verbal teasing only. If your child is being hurt or threatened, involve the school straight away.

“Make friends with the popular kids.”

Why it misfires

Popularity is about status, and the most popular groups are often the hardest to get into.

Try instead

Look for kids who like what your child likes. A shared interest gives them something to talk about and a reason to spend time together.

“Just be friends with everyone.”

Why it misfires

Friendship is a choice. Some kids tease, ignore your child, or get them into trouble, and effort spent there is effort taken from kids who would welcome it.

Try instead

Help your child notice who treats them well, and put their energy there.

Playing together, and hosting a get-together

Being easy to be around beats being right.

“Make sure everyone follows the rules.”

Why it misfires

Policing a casual game reads as bossy, even when your child is right. The other kids remember the refereeing long after they have forgotten the rule.

Try instead

Let small things go in casual games, and point out other kids’ good moves. Kids remember who was fun to play with.

“Just invite the other friend over too.”

Why it misfires

When another friend calls or messages during a get-together, adding them leaves the friend who is already there feeling like second choice.

Try instead

One friend at a time. Tell the caller you’re busy and will catch up later. That way the friend who came over knows they were the plan.

Why these shifts work

Where these shifts come from

Each one is based on what socially successful kids and teens do in real friendships. It’s the same approach behind the programs we run at Unified Care Solutions: PEERS® for teenagers and Children’s Friendship Training (CFT) for primary school-aged children. Parents are trained alongside as their child’s coach, so the skills get used at home, at school and at weekends, where friendships happen.

Using any skill is always the young person’s choice. The aim is for other kids to see who they already are.

What to do next

Start with one.

1. Pick one

Choose the piece of advice your child hears most, and swap it for the alternative this week.

2. Coach after the moment

Keep it short: what went well, and what they would try next time.

3. Talk to us

We can work out together what matters most for your child right now. See our primary school and secondary school programs.

Common questions

Friendship and autistic kids: what parents ask

Why does my autistic child find it hard to make friends?

Often it comes down to a mismatch between how your child approaches people and the unspoken rules other kids follow. Much of the advice kids are given misses those rules, so it doesn’t help. When the rules are taught directly and practised in real settings, kids are much better placed to make and keep friends.

Should my child ignore teasing?

For verbal teasing, ignoring it often keeps it going, because the teaser is after a reaction. A short, bored response that shows it has no effect usually works better. Physical bullying or threats are different: involve the school straight away.

Is teaching friendship skills a form of masking?

The skills are options. Your child decides whether and when to use them, and the aim is for others to see who they already are. Masking is hiding who you are to fit in, and that is never the goal.

Can friendship programs be done by telehealth?

Yes. Unified Care Solutions runs PEERS® and Children’s Friendship Training by telehealth, anywhere in Australia, with a parent or carer joining their own group alongside.

Sound like we could help?

Call 0429 535 452 or email reception@ucsol.com.au

Book a call
Previous
Previous

Preparing for an NDIS plan reassessment: what's changed and what evidence helps

Next
Next

Providers have had it good in the NDIS for a long time. Now we owe something back.